• Home
  • Services
    • Net Zero Accelerator
    • Sustainability/Net Zero Strategy
    • Employee Engagement for Sustainability
    • Professional Development for Sustainability (CPD)
  • Net Zero Business Academy
  • Our Clients
  • About Us
  • Gareth’s Blog
  • Sustainability Resources
  • Contact Us

Call us on 0191 265 7899

info@terrainfirma.co.uk
Terra Infirma Terra Infirma Terra Infirma Terra Infirma
Bringing Sustainability
to Life
  • Home
  • Services
    • Net Zero Accelerator
    • Sustainability/Net Zero Strategy
    • Employee Engagement for Sustainability
    • Professional Development for Sustainability (CPD)
  • Net Zero Business Academy
  • Our Clients
  • About Us
  • Gareth’s Blog
  • Sustainability Resources
  • Contact Us

Taxing CSR Issues

Home UncategorizedTaxing CSR Issues

Taxing CSR Issues

20th December 2010 Uncategorized 1 Comment

Very interesting article in the Observer yesterday about tax avoidance and the UK Uncut campaign who maintain that the current UK austerity package would be unnecessary if there was a crackdown on tax avoidance. Sir Philip Green, boss of the Arcadia Group which owns Topshop, is attracting particular ire as Arcadia is actually owned by his wife who is resident in Monaco. And, of course, Topshop is a tall poppy – a sit-in in a depot in Basingstoke won’t attract much publicity compared to one in an Oxford Street megastore.
While Green is an obvious case of stretching the rules, it’s never clear where canny accounting becomes tax avoidance. Like all businesses I employ an accountant who has two main roles – getting all the paperwork together and making sure I’m paying the correct amount of tax. ‘Correct’ could be interpreted as ‘not a penny more than I have to within reason’. And therein, I suppose, lies the rub – the definition of ‘within reason’. I wouldn’t offshore my business or transferring ownership to minimise tax – easy to say when the issue doesn’t arise – but for Green that’s clearly OK in his mind.
Similar shades-of-grey arguments lie in a range of corporate social responsibility (CSR) issues. If we offshore functions to, say, Bangalore where salaries are lower, what does that do to the economy of our ‘home’ country? If we exclude Bangalore, what does that do to the career prospects of burgeoning middle classes of India? Do we want those people to give up software engineering and call centre operations and go back to subsistence farming? But by getting nations to compete against each other for big business, are we encouraging a ‘race to the bottom’ where the lowest labour and environmental standards win? And, where is ‘home’ for an transnational corporation anyway?
These are extremely difficult issues. The important thing for a company which trades on its CSR is to have a framework within which decisions relating to such issues can be made. A company with a geographic tradition (dare I suggest Cadbury? or U2?) should consider carefully where they are registered or they will lay themselves wide open to attack. A company whose business model depends on low manufacturing costs (eg high street fashion) should have a strict policy on pay and other working conditions within their supply chain.
If you don’t have such a framework, you will be measured against other people’s yardstick which will inevitably be tougher than your own. If you are targeted you won’t get off the back foot. So set the standard and enforce it. If it works, then raise the bar. Make it work for you and be proud of it.

Tags: corporate social responsibilitycsroffshorephilip greensupply chaintaxtopshop
1 Comment
0
Share

1 Comment

Leave your reply.

Leave a Reply

Your email is safe with us.
Cancel Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Subscribe to The Low Carbon Agenda – your free monthly guide to implementing Sustainability

* indicates required

Contact Information

  • Gareth Kane
  • Terra Infirma Limited
  • 157 Stratford Road, Newcastle upon Tyne NE6 5AS
  • 0191 265 7899
  • info@terrainfirma.co.uk
Follow @GarethKane

Twitter Feed

Tweets by GarethKane

Latest Blogs

Jonathan Oxley of the CBI on on Net Zero, Beyond Petroleum, CBAM, Government Policy and much more

1st December 2023

A fantastic and informative interview with Jonathan Oxley, a...

Are Science-based Targets now coming into their own underpinning Net Zero?

28th November 2023

When Science-based Targets (SBTs) first emerged in 2015, I...

© Terra Infirma 2018 | All Rights Reserved | Site designed and created by Resilient Business Systems