• Home
  • Services
    • Net Zero Accelerator
    • Sustainability/Net Zero Strategy
    • Employee Engagement for Sustainability
    • Professional Development for Sustainability (CPD)
  • Net Zero Business Academy
  • Our Clients
  • About Us
  • Gareth’s Blog
  • Sustainability Resources
  • Contact Us

Call us on 0191 265 7899

info@terrainfirma.co.uk
Terra Infirma Terra Infirma Terra Infirma Terra Infirma
Bringing Sustainability
to Life
  • Home
  • Services
    • Net Zero Accelerator
    • Sustainability/Net Zero Strategy
    • Employee Engagement for Sustainability
    • Professional Development for Sustainability (CPD)
  • Net Zero Business Academy
  • Our Clients
  • About Us
  • Gareth’s Blog
  • Sustainability Resources
  • Contact Us

Reframing the environment vs economy argument

Home UncategorizedReframing the environment vs economy argument

Reframing the environment vs economy argument

6th July 2012 Uncategorized No Comments

In my keynote speech at the Energy & Environment North East 2012 conference, I argued that the question was not low carbon or growth, but low carbon or stagnation. Now the CBI has released a report arguing exactly the same thing:

With a technical double-dip recession now a reality and private sector growth at the top of the agenda, some are questioning whether there is still room for ‘going green’. The business response is definitive and emphatic: green is not just complementary to growth, but a vital driver of it [my emphasis].

In trying economic times, the UK’s green business has continued to grow in real terms, carving out a £122 billion share of a global market worth £3.3 trillion and employing close to a million people. And in 2014/15, it is expected to roughly halve the UK’s trade deficit.

Stirring stuff. But also a vital reminder of the importance of framing arguments when it comes to making the case for sustainability. Too many politicians, media commentators and business leaders have a default view that ‘green’ is a luxury, expensive and/or a communist plot at the best of times, never mind during “the current economic situation.” The statistics are showing us is that green growth is the only way forward, but many choose to ignore them.

This arises because we all perceive the rest of the world through a ‘frame’ which blocks out most of the picture and allows us to isolate the things or issues we perceive to be important. We have to do this or we would simply be overwhelmed with information, but the downside is that what we see through the frame may not represent the bigger picture. Before coming to an important decision, it is always worth questioning our default frame and maybe trying a different frame to see if it makes a difference – testing our assumptions in other words.

The ‘reframing’ process is extremely important at an organisational level too. “If it’s a choice between profit or the environment, my boss always chooses profit.” someone complained to me recently. That’s an argument they are very unlikely to win unless they can reframe the argument to “environment and profit.” Getting someone to change their default frame is not straightforward, but there are a number of options:

  • The opinions of someone the person trusts – the CBI report is very powerful because that group is anything but a group of lefty beardy tree huggers. I often quote the International Energy Agency for exactly the same reason;
  • Use questions – questions are disarming and get people thinking. I start my workshops by asking “Why should we take sustainability seriously?” which encourages delegates to make the case to themselves;
  • Frame presentations and arguments carefully – if I started my workshops with “Should we take sustainability seriously?” then that is quite a different frame and puts the onus on me to argue ‘yes’.

Chesterton said “Art consists of limitation. The most beautiful part of every picture is the frame.” It is also the most important part of any argument, so choose your frame carefully.

 

Tags: business caseculture changegreen jujitsu
No Comments
0
Share

Leave a Reply

Your email is safe with us.
Cancel Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Subscribe to The Low Carbon Agenda – your free monthly guide to implementing Sustainability

* indicates required

Contact Information

  • Gareth Kane
  • Terra Infirma Limited
  • 157 Stratford Road, Newcastle upon Tyne NE6 5AS
  • 0191 265 7899
  • info@terrainfirma.co.uk
Follow @GarethKane

Twitter Feed

Tweets by GarethKane

Latest Blogs

Should we bin the phrase ‘Net Zero’?

4th December 2023

At the weekend I was listening to a debate on Net Zero on...

Jonathan Oxley of the CBI on on Net Zero, Beyond Petroleum, CBAM, Government Policy and much more

1st December 2023

A fantastic and informative interview with Jonathan Oxley, a...

© Terra Infirma 2018 | All Rights Reserved | Site designed and created by Resilient Business Systems