I’ve had it with talk of a ‘just transition’

© satori13, istockphoto.com
Reading the paper this morning (I’m so Gen X…), I was struck by two articles relating to COP31. The first was a list of the biggest exporters of CO2 (ie from fossil fuel exports) in history. The top five were: Russia, Saudia Arabia, Australia, Venezuela, and Iran – only Australia stands out as a bastion of liberal democracy; all the others have autocratic regimes and terrible human rights records. Most of these regimes would not exist if they weren’t funded by the rest of us buying their coal, oil and gas.
The second story (or editorial to be precise), reflected on the terrible flash flood from a collapsing glacier in Nepal in August. 1500 people are known to have died and 5000 are unaccounted for. Reconstruction will cost $5bn, but the international community has only ponied up $20m for Nepal from the Loss and Damage Fund, set up at a COP meeting four years ago. It has long been said that the poorest in the world will be hit hardest by climate change – the plight of Nepal brings that harshly to light.
One of the problems with change is psychologically we have a skewed perspective of the status quo and the post-transition state. In particular, we downplay the negatives of ‘do nothing’ and exaggerate the downsides of change. Within the climate movement, this manifests itself as the concept of the ‘just transition’, but is that just a comfort blanket?
On the radio last week I heard complaints about materials in EV batteries (ie cobalt extraction in the DRC) from presenters I’ve never heard wring their hands over, say, a laptop battery with identical chemistry. Likewise concerns that 20% of solar panel raw materials are made under forced labour never seem to be applied to similar concerns in the consumer electronics or garment industries. At a climate march I attended last year, one speaker said “we can’t tackle climate change until we have peace in the Middle East.” Trade Unions regularly cite ‘just transition’ to keep jobs in the fossil fuel sector which by definition won’t exist in a low carbon economy. Do all these people just want to sit on their sofas and keep funding tyrants and watch poor people washed away by floods? Is that OK?
Of course we should strive to make the low carbon transition as fair as possible, but the biggest injustice would be to do nothing at all.